On the Island of Misfit Toys

“Two months ago I was homeless and living in my car behind the Recovery House downtown,” said a guy in a meeting I was at recently, “and my life has turned around so quickly it is unbelievable.”  He went on to explain that, since he stopped practicing his addiction and started doing what was suggested by others in recovery, he had managed to get a job, find a place to live in sober housing, and—best of all, he said—start sleeping through the night. “This morning when I awoke, it was light outside, not dark, and I cannot tell you how long it has been since that happened.”  He concluded his comments with this: “I am so grateful to be an addict, since I now know where I belong, and that is here, with you guys, where I can find friendship and fellowship and unconditional love.”

Grateful to be an addict?  Really?  Yeah, really.  Most of us are, for we understand that without having been brought to our knees through utter and complete defeat and incomprehensible demoralization, we never would have asked for help, never would have been able to change our lives, and, most of all, never would have found a fellowship where we belonged, where we were loved unconditionally and accepted without qualification.  After all, the traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous say that, as to qualifications for joining AA, “the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.” So anyone who wants to do things differently is welcome, and that is true for any Twelve Step fellowship.

Now, it is this idea that we addicts found our home in the rooms of recovery that I want to consider here, for in it are profound lessons for Christians of all stripes.

Any practicing addict, at least during those rare moments when she or he can be candid about the power of the addiction, will tell you that the most despairing thing about our condition is that we have burned all bridges, we have alienated those we love, and that, at the deepest level, we feel as if we don’t really fit in with the rest of society. For me, it always felt like, when they were handing out Instruction Manuals on How to Live Life, I didn’t get one.  In short, we addicts feel like total misfits.  So it is that we experience relief and joy beyond description once we finally stumble upon the Island of Misfit Toys—better known, of course, as AA or NA or any of the other Twelve Step fellowships.  We finally belong somewhere, we have a home and a spiritual family, and it is only by watching and imitating our new brothers and sisters that we can become sane and sound and functioning members of society, learning to love and serve and be content in the everyday.

I suggest that Christians have lost this sense of wonder and joy at being unconditionally loved and accepted in a spiritual family, and that the reason for this is because we have lost the sense of brokenness and emptiness and because we no longer feel deeply the need for God.  Now, I am the last to want to go back to the days where churches were places of guilt and shame and abusive systems of coercion, but, of course, those places were never really churches at all, at least not in the New Testament sense.

Once I wrote an academic paper on a passage from Philippians, and in studying the early church at Philippi, I was struck by how isolated they felt from the Roman society in which they lived, how deeply they understood that they were different from their fellow Roman citizens.  When everyone else was greeting one another by saying, “Caesar is Lord,” the Christians would respond, “no, Jesus is Lord.”  Now while this may have been a sound and strong theological response, it could not have done much for one’s sense of belonging.  But they knew that they had a true home, and that it was in the rooms of gathering, the church rooms, where they were welcomed and belonged. They knew that they had stumbled upon Jesus’ Island of Misfit Toys.

So it is that in this society of ours, our society of narcissism and materialism and secularism, where to acknowledge brokenness or sin or a deep need for God is considered bad form at best and at worst is taken as instability, where to speak out in the name of Christ will get you labeled as a danger to the regime, we Christians have a home, a place where we belong, and a place where—like our friends the addicts—we can be transformed one day at a time, to go out and love and serve the world in joy and peace.


About Kelly Clark

I am a convinced, if not very virtuous, Christian, recovering from alcohol abuse and many other addictions, and have been working a program of recovery consistently for over nineteen years-- since I blew my life up with chaos and crimes and hurt many people I loved. I am active in 12 Step Fellowships, sponsoring several men and attending several meetings each week. I expect to finish a Masters of Divinity in the Fall of 2011, and soon will begin a discernment process in my church about possible ordained ministry. In my day job, I am a trial attorney, representing adult victims of childhood sexual abuse.
This entry was posted in Christianity and the 12 Steps. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to On the Island of Misfit Toys

  1. I agree. By virtue of our innate broken state, we humans are all in some sort of recovering process which requires interdependent support. Your writing is consistently insightful. I hope you will find a social or traditional media avenue which maximizes readership. Brad

  2. Castimonia says:

    I like what Helen Keller wrote, “I thank God for my handicaps, for through them I have found myself, my work, and my God.” I feel the same about my addiction (and moreso, my recovery).

  3. Steph says:

    The story was good but I was disappointed to get to the end of a holiday recovery story to find a video ad for Corona Beer… Not a good choice.

  4. Kelly M. says:

    I’m not an addict, but this touched me so much. I have a different cross to bear. I struggle with major depression. There’s very little in the way of affordable care for me right now and what I can get is very stigmatized. I can’t let certain people in my life know when I’m struggling or I will be back in family court. There is so much confusion between depression and some kind of break with reality! Anyway, this was exactly the message I needed to hear, right now, today. I am so thankful that you wrote this. Even when my neurochemistry won’t co-operate, when I can’t seem to feel any happiness appropriate to the situation and I feel like I stick out like a sore thumb, I have refuge and joy in Christ.

    Thank you for this ministering, Kelly

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s